I decided last night that Erin was one of my front-runners... and then he didn't pick her! 
She may not have been the smartest or most athletic, but I think she was super cute and normal. I think she was just relaxed and not involved in the competitive BS. I thought they had a connection on that date and in the car... but maybe she just didn't show enough interest.
I came to the conclusion, that although andy is hot... he is just a nerd in a hot guy's body. Don't get me wrong, i like him a lot and i think he is genuine... I just think the nerd in him felt that Erin was out of his league.
.... so instead he chose girls like TINA ?! Stephanie?!? and Nicole?!?!
ugh bad move.